How to Get an Alligator in Fisch

Careful, it bites!

Written by
Published on . Updated Nov 3, 2026, 8:12 AM UTC
More Fisch Guides

Alligators are one of the earliest Legendary fish that you'll have to catch in Fisch, among many more. Catching an alligator is the key to unlocking a very powerful early-game rod, and getting one is easy if you know where to look.

In this guide, we'll show you the best spot to fish for it, what rods to use, and even show you how to get a free pet that helps speed up the fishing minigame.

Where to Catch Alligators

From the starting island of Moosewood, spawn your ship and align yourself between northwest (NW) and north (N), then sail forth. As you enter the ocean, you should see a label for Mushgrove Swamp on your screen.

Head straight for Mushgrove Swamp and get off once you touch land.

Mushgrove Swamp in Fisch

Proceed to the Mushgrove Skin Merchant NPC, who is standing beside a large red and white dotted mushroom. Behind him is a small boat, which is the ideal spot for catching alligators.

The Mushgrove Skin Merchant and boat in Fisch

If you have the Fish Radar, you can activate it to show the exact spot where you have the highest odds of reeling in an alligator. Without one of these, just make sure that you cast your bobber as close as possible to the boat.

The Fish Radar showing the exact alligator catching spot in Fisch

Best Rods to Use

The best rod to use here will be whichever you have that has the highest luck. If you're a new player, the choice is between a Carbon Rod or the Lucky Rod, both of which can be bought at Moosewood.

The Carbon and Lucky Rod in Fisch

Alligator's Preferences

Here's a breakdown with the alligator's preferences, so you'll know when it's the best time to try catching it:

Bait

Time

Season

Weather

Fish Head, Bagel (low budget option)

Night

Spring

Rain or Foggy

Aside from these, keep an eye out for Sovereign weather events or Aurora Borealis, which boost your overall luck. These are frequently active in most servers as people manually activate them.

Holding an Alligator in Fisch

Free Companion - Gary Gator

You must be at least level 30 before you can do this!

Mushgrove Swamp is also home to another type of alligator, a special pet named Gary Gator. He is one of the best early game companions in Fisch as he will periodically speed up your fishing progress.

He appears in the same location where you catch alligators. Once you spot a roaming alligator in the water, you'll need to equip Fish Head bait and then cast your rod. DO NOT shake, as this is different from catching a normal fish.

Gary Gator in Fisch

While your bobber is on the water with Fish Head bait attached, Gary Gator will slowly make his way towards you. As long as you don't start the fishing minigame, he will eventually touch your bobber and become unlocked as a companion.

If done correctly and successfully, you should see a message saying: [Companion Unlocked: Gary Gator].

Gary Gator unlock message in Fisch

To equip him, simply open your Companion Satchel and press the Equip button under his icon!

The Companion Satchel and Gary Gator in Fisch

Fungal Rod Quest

Near the alligator fishing spot is an NPC named Agaric. Speak with him and he'll task you with catching and handing over an alligator caught on the same island.

Agaric in Fisch

Simply hold an alligator in your hands and speak with him to complete the quest. As a reward, he'll give you the Fungal Rod.

The Fungal Rod and Agaric in Fisch

This is a fantastic early game rod as it has a 70% chance to give you a 50% luck boost (45 seconds long) after every catch. It also has a decent chance to give you fish with the Fungal mutation, which grants a large 4x value boost.